Travel Stories

Would You Rather: Beach & Island Life Edition

In our second episode of our Would You Rather series, we’re diving headfirst into sunshine, salty air, and all the island vibes you can handle. It’s a full-on travel showdown: Would You Rather: Beach…

Sofia Wardell 3 min read

In our second episode of our Would You Rather series, we’re diving headfirst into sunshine, salty air, and all the island vibes you can handle. It’s a full-on travel showdown: Would You Rather: Beach & Island Life Edition! So grab your coconuts (or cocktails), because we’re hitting up Greece, Bali, the Maldives, Costa Rica, and beyond!


Greece vs. Bali: Island-Hopping or Beach Bumming?

️ We both said: GREECE!

We’re all about island-hopping vibes — think Santorini sunsets, Mykonos parties, and quiet gems like Zakynthos and Milos. Want the best cruise recs? We gotchu:

Celebrity Cruises – Greek Island Routes
Celestyal Cruises – Authentic Greek Vibes
Windstar Cruises – Yacht-Style Romance
Seabourn – Ultra Luxe & Culture

But hey, Bali isn’t just chillin’ in the corner. It’s got major surf, stunning cliffside beaches, and killer snorkeling. If you’re chasing waves and epic sunsets, don’t miss:

Uluwatu Beach – Surf & Views
Seminyak – Trendy Vibes & Nightlife
Amed Beach – Shipwreck Snorkeling

Full Moon in Thailand or Bonfire in Hawaii?

Sof said: Hawaii. All the way.
Natalie: Team Thailand, baby!

What even is a Full Moon Party? Only the wildest all-night beach rave ever, hosted in Koh Phangan, Thailand. Think neon paint, fire dancers, insane DJ sets, and thousands of people from around the world.

Guide to the Full Moon Party
Where it Happens – Haad Rin Beach

Prefer something chill and soul-soothing? Picture this: Hawaiian beach bonfire, ukulele music, and stargazing with friends. Yeah, we’re down for that too.

Top Bonfire Spots in Hawaii

‍♀️ Learn to Surf in Costa Rica or Paddleboard in the Maldives?

BOTH sound dreamy. But we’re currently obsessed with the Maldives️ and those overwater bungalows. Our bucket list is growing fast…

‍♀️ Soneva Fushi – Eco-Luxe & Stargazing
Anantara Veli – Adults Only Romance
Vakkaru Maldives – Snorkel + Spa Goals

But don’t sleep on Costa Rica, especially if you’re a surfer girl (or guy). Check out:

‍♂️ Tamarindo – Great for Beginners
Santa Teresa – Laid-back Surf Town
Witch’s Rock – Epic Waves & Adventure

Chill in the Caribbean or Party in Ibiza?

This was a toss-up!
Sof: Ibiza, duh.
Natalie: Pass me a coconut on the beach.

Top Clubs in Ibiza:
Hï Ibiza
Ushuaïa
DC-10
Pacha
O Beach

Best Caribbean Beaches to Relax:
Grace Bay, Turks and Caicos
Pink Sands Beach, Bahamas
Shoal Bay, Anguilla
Flamenco Beach, Puerto Rico

️ Live on a Sailboat in the Bahamas or Beachfront in Tulum?

This one had us split.
Sof: Sailboat ALL the way. (Tulum’s gotten a little sketchy lately.)
Natalie: Tulum, please! (Lived on a boat already — been there, done that!)

Bahamas Island-Hopping Musts:
Exumas – Swim with Pigs
Andros – Best Diving in the Bahamas
Harbour Island – Pink Sands & Chic Vibes

Tulum Perks (and Precautions):
Tulum Travel Safety Tips
Top Beachfront Hotels in Tulum
Navigating Tulum’s Party Scene

Drop Us a Comment!

Which destination would you pick? Greece or Bali? Surf or spa? Coconut chill or Ibiza rave?
DM us @thetravelbrats or leave a comment below! We want to hear all about your dream vacay vibes

Follow + Subscribe

Listen on Spotify
Listen on Apple Podcasts
Watch on YouTube
Instagram
TikTok
Threads
Facebook
X / Twitter

Keep reading